We had to see who would win the ultimate chocolate, marshmallow and graham cracker showdown.
McDonald’s S’mores McFlurry vs Dairy Queen’s S’mores Blizzard: Who Has the Better Summertime Ice Cream?
Published on Jun. 12, 2025
It’s about that time when every fast-food menu slips a new s’mores something-or-other into the desserts section. You see, s’mores have quite a history, and they’re basically synonymous with summer now. Let’s not pretend that this iconic trio—sweet chocolate, gooey marshmallow and crunchy graham cracker—isn’t the quintessential summer treat. And you know who else recognizes the s’more as a summer powerhouse? Our trusty Golden Arches and the Dairy Queen herself.
When I first laid eyes upon the upcoming S’mores McFlurry, I absolutely knew I had to get in there for a taste. And what better way to discern which s’mores is the best than with a side-by-side comparison with a tried-and-true? A little competition never hurt anyone (especially when it means I get to try two different kinds of ice cream).
When did McDonald’s come out with a S’mores McFlurry?
McDonald’s officially dropped its S’mores McFlurry on June 10, just a few days ago. Was I there day one? Absolutely. I pulled up to the drive-thru, excitedly ordered my brand-new McFlurry and waited to be graced by its presence. I was stunned by the amount of delicious mini marshmallows, chocolate chunks and graham cracker crumbles as soon as I was handed the cardboard cup. While I wanted to dig in, I safely placed it in my cupholder and made my way down the road to my childhood Dairy Queen. Fun fact, it was built in 1953! There’s nothing like a little DQ nostalgia.
Now, the S’mores Blizzard isn’t new. It actually debuted on the Dairy Queen menu back in 2013, and it’s been a regular addition to the menu ever since. And, as you might have guessed, there’s a reason for that. It’s sensational. The S’mores Blizzard is actually one of my favorite Blizzard flavors of all-time. If I could find a comparable competitor, I’d be over the moon. Thus, with my overflowing S’mores Blizzard in hand, I began the taste test.
Which dessert won the taste test?
I gave them both a thorough, unbiased taste. And yet, Dairy Queen still retained her crown. She’s royalty for a reason, you know.
As much as I loved the look of the S’mores McFlurry, I came to find that it wasn’t premixed with anything at all, and the toppings instead sat upon a cupful of plain vanilla soft serve. After mixing in all the toppings, I found it was incredibly sparse when it came to actual s’mores components. The mini marshmallows were crunchy and tasted more artificial than I wanted. The chocolate bits, while still tasty, were much smaller than those in the Blizzard. And the graham cracker pieces weren’t even present enough for me to notice. I needed much, much more of a s’mores presence than I got. It mostly tasted like vanilla soft serve with a few random inclusions.
Now, the S’mores Blizzard was overflowing from the start. I’m surprised it survived the flip test. Mix-ins made it into every bite, including massive chunks of chocolate and plenty of crushed graham cracker. And while it didn’t have actual marshmallows, each bite had a wicked amount of marshmallow flavor that complemented the heft of the chocolate. And, on top of everything, the soft serve base was super creamy. I’d cleaned out the Blizzard in the blink of an eye and wanted another!
Should you still try the S’mores McFlurry for yourself? You’ll always be your own best critic. But, if you’re looking for a consistent, delicious s’mores ice cream treat, Dairy Queen really can’t be beat.
Related:
